<Disclaimer>
This is an updated repost of my previous review.
My original review of this resource will continue below.
Just to clarify any confusion that any would-be customers may have when looking at the recent reviews and the resource author's response, I will recap what has happened and let you form your own opinion.
Some days ago I posted a negative review of Spartan. This is the same review that will follow this update. It is my belief that as a paying customer, I have the right to let any perspective customers hear my own personal experience with both this product and its author.
While I generally do not post reviews, my review was prompted by Evan going out of his way to blatantly manipulate reviews by outright buying them. He, in his discord server, posted an advert that in exchange for users leaving a 5 star review, yielded them another of his (paid) plugins free of charge.
While I volunteer my time to both help with support and develop a support bot for a direct competitor to this anticheat, at the end of the day I am still a server owner who has genuinely uses and tests both products regularly. Out of respect for Vagdedes, I will not name this competitor.
Following my my review, Vagdedes (henceforth referred to as Evan) reached out to my close friend and leader of the competing project that I volunteer my time, Frap, with and threatened both legal action and blackmail. You can view his exact message here:
http://bit.ly/3FXMiZ5
Following this, frap decided to drop an @everyone ping to bring attention to Evan's threats, which is well within his rights to do. In Frap's announcement, there was no call for any attack of any kind. Here is a direct quote from this announcement: "I also don't wish for anyone to assault/attack Spartan or Evan, I am simply just putting some facts out there and my own recent experiences with him, which are deeply troubling to me."
Following that, Evan also pinged @everyone in his community, in which he showcased Frap's response and called Frap's community 'unmoderated'.
Presumably due to the *8 thousand* people who got a ping bringing their attention to this conflict, a handful users decided to post reviews in which they detailed their experiences with both this resource and its developer.
In *yet another* blatant abuse of SpigotMC's review system, Evan reached out to SpigotMC staff and had many of the reviews removed for being a ''coordinated attack originating from the 'Frap Development' Discord". This is an outright lie. Both myself and others from the aforementioned discord have gone out of our way to make statements directly contrary to this.
Pinned in the discord, they have a message that directly states: "We do not condone taking any action against any party (including but not limited to spartan and/or their team members)
We do, however, condone leaving honest feedback and reviews of products that you have purchased."
In response to my original review, the author of this resource mentions how he was bullied in the Frap development discord, which he claims has no moderation. This is a blatant lie. We have simply chosen to let people voice their opinions and personal experiences about both this resource and its author without censorship.
Finally, I will also say that the claims and experiences expressed in my review are up-to-date with the version of spartan currently released. As a server owner, I keep myself up-to-date with different anticheat solutions as my own (as well as any other) servers need to stay up-to-date with ever evolving threat that is cheaters.
<Thank you for attending my ted talk, the original review continues below>
TLDR; C tier anticheat brought down by an F tier developer.
I normally don't write reviews since everyone judges things differently and my opinions may not matter to you.
With that said, I will go out of my way to write this review knowing full well that it *will* get me harassed and bullied by its developer.
This anticheat is on par with free anticheats (even manages to be worse than a couple), but this experience is destroyed by any interactions with its developer.
Reviews for either this, or any of Vagdedes's other products cannot be trusted either, weather be they here here or elsewhere. Full stop. It is well known that in exchange for removing a negative review, the developer will refund you your purchase (or even more than the amount of your purchase in some cases). But recently he has taken this to the next level and has started blatantly buying positive reviews.
On his discord, Vagdedes has a channel called '#my-account' with a button labeled 'Get a FREE Plugin!'. This button, when clicked, prompts the user to leave a 5 star review of Spartan in exchange for a free copy of one of his other plugins. This, in tandem with the review manipulation that already takes place is an egregious abuse of the review system.
The anticheat itself is okay, performance is kinda crap and it has a propensity for flagging players who aren't cheating, but as mentioned, its probably about a C tier.
Something that *isn't* advertised on the plugin page is that Spartan will, on its own, decide that a player isn't cheating and simply exempt them for some time. I wouldn't have thought that anyone would have needed to be told how incredibly stupid this is. Anyone can cheat, even users who previously have not.
Another thing of note is that Vagdedes has a history of extremely anti-consumer practices and behaviors. One of the biggest things that comes to mind is that time that he made Spartan just *not* check new players until 6 months after their first join until you subscribed to his (at the time) premium addon, spartan SYN. Both Spartan SYN and this "feature" has since been removed.
Additionally, while the spigot page (currently) *still* advertises support via discord, this is a blatant lie. Discord support was discontinued and instead only offered to users who subscribe to Vagdedes's Patreon.
Users who don't feel like dishing out a monthly fee for support for a C tier plugin are advised to contact him via email, which is... crap. While it is impossible to confirm this, there exists a non-zero chance that he could introduce issues into the plugin to prompt more people to subscribe to his Patreon. Quite literally, he would be getting paid to "fix" issues that he introduced.
Vagdedes, please, I do not want to be contacted regarding this review, thanks.